THE MERMAID & THE ALLIGATOR, Key West – Your ideal downtown stay

The Mermaid & The Alligator - Adults-only bed and breakfast with gardens near Duval Street

Located in Old Town Key West, this 1904 Queen Anne Victorian mansion features angled bay windows, sloping gabled roofs, and spacious verandas. The property includes lush tropical gardens with mature shade trees, exotic plants, and migrating bird sightings. Guests have access to a plunge pool, outdoor seating areas, and complimentary breakfast served poolside. The hotel is a 10-minute walk from Duval Street and Key West International Airport is 10 km away. Staff provide curated local event lists and tour recommendations.

Additional perks of the hotel

Complimentary happy hour with wine and light snacks

On-site massage therapy available

Bike storage and rentals

Conch Tour Train tickets available

Ice machine, pool towels, sunscreen, and beach chairs provided

Guest computer with printer access

Living room with Xfinity-TV and board games

Rooms

The property offers nine unique accommodations including mansion suites and garden cottage rooms. The Caribbean King Suite features a wraparound veranda. The Treetop Suite includes a king bed alcove and open soaking tub, accessible via 40-step staircase. The Audubon Room has French doors leading to garden areas and a Jacuzzi bathtub. Royal Poinciana suite contains an antique writing desk and outside veranda. Ground-floor Garden Room offers terrace access with pool views.

Other conveniences

Tommy Bahama bath amenities

Turkish cotton towels and plush bathrobes

Multi-port electrical outlets with wireless charging

Sound therapy systems

Private entrances for cottage rooms

Synthetic down duvet & pillows

Iron & ironing board

Hair dryer

Safe